![]() |
| Tens of thousands gathered to reclaim Yuen Long on July 27 |
Today a judge sentenced a social worker to one year in jail for impeding a police operation during an anti-government protest, saying he and his peers caused chaos and "dealt a blow" to police work.
On July 27 last year, a week after the horrific attack on people by white-shirted men at the Yuen Long MTR station, protesters came out to the New Territories district to demonstrate against the police's lack of action in this incident.
At the time tens of thousands showed up to support the neighbourhood and to protest against the brutality, when the police did not approve the rally and moved to clear the protesters.
Lau Ka-tung, 24, and two other social workers stood in front of the police cordon, asking police officers to slow down and allow protesters to leave the area.
Lawyers for Lau said he wanted to communicate with the police because he feared officers would cause a stampede if they suddenly charged towards the protesters.
However, the defence failed to convince acting principal magistrate Don So Man-lung, who said social workers on the scene led to chaos and anger, as well as having "fundamentally dealt a blow" to police work.
The magistrate said the social workers prevented the officers from enforcing the law.
"The duty of police is not to rally alongside protesters... Police are entitled to charge at the gathering crowd and jostle protesters to break down their size," So said.
"In the present case, no one was allowed to stop the advancing officers, just as nobody should prevent police from chasing a robber."
How are protesters who have a right to express themselves, and to assemble, be judged on the same level as a robber?
While the defense suggested Lau be punished with a fine, Magistrate So said time in prison was more appropriate considering the magnitude of the obstruction called by Lau and his two colleagues.
This sentence made a lot of social workers upset, because they come to protests specifically to provide any legal advice, to try to negotiate between the protesters and the police, and to be a resource for those needing help during these tense and often violent incidents.
"I am extremely angry," said Cheung Chi-wai, vice-president of the Hong Kong Social Workers' General Union. He made the statement during a press conference alongside lawmakers Shiu Ka-chun and Fernando Cheung Chiu-hung, both social workers by profession.
"The presence of social workers on protest scenes is both lawful and appropriate. It is not open to challenge," Cheung Chi-wai said.
It is shocking that a social worker who was not actively protesting was sentenced to a year in jail for supposedly obstructing the police from doing their work. While police were discharging their duties, so were the social workers. How are they in the wrong?
This is only the beginning. It will be sad to see more and more convictions of this nature.













