 |
A skeletal staff is keeping the paper going to the bitter end
|
Apple Daily is soldiering on to its last days even though some 40 percent of its staff have quit in the last few days.
Many of them resigned when they were told the company would ask the Security Bureau to unfreeze its assets; many believed this request would not be granted. They also quit when they were told they did not need to give one month's notice.
 |
About 40 percent of staff have resigned
|
Some of the reporters who quit were concerned about legal repercussions, while others were determined to continue on to the end.
Among the teams that have packed up and gone were those managing online financial news, English-language coverage, breaking news and video content called "Apple Action News". Sections still running are local news, courts, features, entertainment, sports and photography.
"People who are doing their best even though we know the paper could shut down at any time, and teams have started to share workloads in order to make the paper publish as usual," said a journalist who has been at the paper for over a decade.
"The finance team is helping to work on local news, while the breaking news team is helping with interviewing colleagues as they do not have enough manpower to work outside."
 |
Lam refused to answer an Apple Daily question
|
One of the three
Apple Daily executives who was released on bail, Cheung Chi-wai, who was director of the tabloid's digital platform, has resigned.
Meanwhile one Apple Daily reporter tried one last time to get Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor to respond to a question during the weekly press conference:
"You said the national security law only affected a small number of people. But more than 800 people from my company were forced to lose our jobs. Can you respond, Mrs Lam?"
She left the auditorium without answering.
So this is a great victory for China and Xi Jinping -- just in time for the 100th anniversary of the Chinese Communist Party, to see the end of its most outspoken foe.
But it was hardly a fair fight.
 |
Shutting Apple Daily is a hollow win for China
|
It reminds me of C.S. Lewis' book,
The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe, where the White Witch has the lion Aslan tied up with rope before she kills him.
The imagery of the helpless lion is similar to the newspaper trying to keep going in the last few days, its leader Jimmy Lai Chee-ying in jail, and lots of loyal readers willing to buy the paper even if its pages are blank.
Even when Apple Daily is shuttered, this will not change people's opinions about the paper; in fact they will have fonder memories of it and reinforce their attitude towards the government and Beijing.
Is this the way to win people's hearts and minds?